When it comes to suicide prevention, cultural awareness is extremely important. Every culture has their own views of suicide, stemming from their histories and belief systems. Therefore, not everyone addresses suicide prevention efforts in the same ways. Here is a look at how various cultures from around the world have historically viewed suicide and how some of them approach prevention.
Eastern Views and Approaches to Suicide
Historically, countries in Eastern cultures have had a more positive view of suicide than those in Western cultures. For example, in some Asian countries, suicide used to be viewed as a noble or honorable act. China is one example of an Eastern country that has shifted its view on suicide over time. Suicide was seen as honorable when it was done for social or political causes. It was even viewed highly when Confucianism was the main philosophy throughout the country. China saw their worst rates of suicide in the 1990s. [1] However, the rates dramatically declined in the decades to follow. There may be several factors at play. One possibility is fast economic growth. Another factor could be surveillance-based monitoring of students on college campuses. [2] China has also been working to reduce air pollution, as some studies have shown a connection between air pollution and suicide rates. [3]
Japan is another Eastern country that has shifted its perceptions of suicide. Its general attitude toward suicide has been described as “tolerant.” [4] Similar to China, Japanese cultures have historically viewed suicide as honorable or “morally responsible” when it’s performed as a ritual. Also similar to China, Japan experienced a spike in suicide rates in the 1990s when they experienced an economic crisis. However, unlike China, Japan’s rates have not recovered to the extent that China has seen. Japan has, though, been working toward getting its rates down. In 2006, the government initiated a national suicide prevention strategy that helped reduce suicide rates by 35% by the year 2022. [5] This strategy along with other prevention efforts have helped the topic of suicide to be less of a taboo in Japanese culture. Instead, it is starting to be seen as a legitimate health concern.
Western Views and Approaches to Suicide
Western cultures have historically had a much more negative view of suicide compared to Eastern cultures. In these cultures, suicide is often seen as shameful and cowardly. It is also considered illegal in some places. In fact, the term “commit suicide” comes from when suicide was a crime and those who survived suicide could be imprisoned. [6] Much of the stigma surrounding suicide stemmed from Judeo-Christian beliefs and teachings that have been prominent in Western cultures. These teachings considered suicide immoral and punishable. While these religious overtones may no longer be as prominent, the stigma has lingered. This has caused many to struggle in silence, feeling ashamed and hesitant to get help.
Historically, Western cultures have had a more clinical approach to suicide. They focus on identifying and treating mental illness that may be associated with it. This differs from other cultures. In more recent years, however, the topic of mental health has been more openly talked about. Wider prevention strategies started being put into place. For example, the 2024 National Strategy for Suicide Prevention was developed in the U.S. as a 10-year, whole-of-society approach to preventing suicide. Rather than only focusing on the clinical aspect, this strategy addressed health equity and community-based prevention methods.
African Views and Approaches to Suicide
Cultures in African countries also have their own unique perspectives when it comes to how they view and handle the topic of suicide. The cultures and belief systems throughout Africa vary greatly depending on the region. Many cultures view suicide as a taboo topic. This is often due to fear and unknowns surrounding mental health and illness in these cultures. Belief systems play into this, as well, with some cultures viewing suicide as the result of evil spirits or inherited curses. In some countries, such as Ghana and Uganda, suicide is punishable by law and can have severe consequences for the person’s family and community. [7]
Historically, there was an assumption that countries in Africa had low suicide rates. However, this was likely due to a lack of reporting and studies on suicide deaths in African countries. It has since been found that suicide is a public health concern. [8] Due to the vast diversity of culture and lack of data, suicide prevention strategies for African regions have been difficult to implement and research. However, many African cultures highly value community-based efforts. Traditional healers are important in many countries. One example is in South Africa. They have played a crucial role in helping people at risk of suicide. [9]
Indigenous Views and Approaches to Suicide
Indigenous cultures have struggled with significantly higher rates of suicide than non-Indigenous cultures, specifically in North America. [10] There are many factors that play a role in this, including generational trauma, loss of cultural identity, and issues related to poverty. Many Indigenous communities see suicide as a symptom of their broader collective trauma. However, many of these cultures have had stigmatized views of suicide for generations, making it difficult to approach the subject and receive help.
Because community is at the heart of Indigenous culture, Indigenous-specific approaches to suicide prevention often prioritize community-based and culturally grounded practices. This might include performing ceremonies, storytelling, connecting with the land, and finding ways to celebrate and honor their culture. [11] Elders also play a central role in supporting youth and restoring these generational and cultural ties. Rather than focusing on the individual, Indigenous strategies aim to heal the collective spirit and restore harmony within the entire community.
Suicide occurs in all countries and cultures. However, there are different ways to approach it. These methods should specifically resonate with the people who are affected. Learning about cultural differences helps us understand and stay aware that some forms of prevention may be more appropriate than others. The overarching theme, though, appears to be the need for community and meaning. Even though this may be found and approached in different ways, everyone needs to know that they matter to others and that their life has significance.
Sources:
[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352827323000071
[2] https://www.healthdisgroup.us/articles/APM-5-125.php
[3] https://news.ucsb.edu/2024/021373/clearing-air-reduces-suicide-rates
[4] https://www.suicidecleanup.com/culture-and-suicidal-behavior/
[6] https://learning.nspcc.org.uk/news/why-language-matters/rethinking-language-suicide
[7] https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.549404/full
[8] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1876201823004355
[10] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3483901/
[11] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9588522/
About David A. Jobes Ph.D. ABPP
